Medical mailbox
TB Skin Test Results Cause Her to Doubt Original Diagnosis
By Cory SerVaas, M.D.
Published: May/June 2001

Dear Dr. SerVaas: I would like to tell the person about the restless legs that I have had all my life. Many, many nights were spent walking the floor. I started taking Tranxene ten years ago, and I never have the problem unless I cut back on my dosage.

Something I would love to know. Fifty-two years ago, I was taken from my husband and two-year-old baby and sent to a sanitarium for TB for a year. I was of the opinion that once you have the bug, you always test positive. I had a test recently and it was negative. They couldn't believe it, so they did a second test. It was also negative. Could it be possible I didn't have it to start with? I had pneumonia three times, which left calcium on one lung. I am 77. For some reason, this bugs me. At the time, it was very traumatic.

Margaret Shupe
Hinton, West Virginia

Dear Reader: Your story is so reminiscent. This very same thing happened to my aunt in the 1930s. She was taken from her home, husband, and three young children and put in a sanitarium for many months. She had a spina bifida baby before doctors developed ways to treat the condition. My aunt was exhausted from caring for the child, who lived to be about four years old. I relate this because that is why everyone thought she came down with TB.

Fortunately, like you, my aunt survived the quarantine treatment. She lived a productive life and died recently at age 99!

I must say that medicine has come a long way in handling tuberculosis. Infectious disease experts at the American Lung Association tell us that a TB skin test may become negative due to the aging process. It is always a possibility that the original diagnosis of TB was wrong. However, the fact that the skin test is now negative is not proof that you never had the disease.



Article reprinted from the May/June 2001 issue of The Saturday Evening Post magazine. Read more at www.satevepost.org, © Copyright 2005 Benjamin Franklin Literary & Medical Society, All rights reserved