In “Jailhouse Blues” (Jan/Feb 2013), Todd Pitock argues that the practice of containing and isolating inmates in the prison system does little to curb crime or deter repeat offenders.
The Post has covered the question of reform vs. contain in America’s prisons since the 1800s. The following articles from our archives, and a more recent video from the Council for Unity, take additional looks at this controversial topic.
Bob DeSena started the Council for Unity to reform inmates who had been sentenced for violent crimes related to gang activity. In this video, ex-gang member Jason Diadema tells how the program has helped him.
In 1822, the Pennsylvania Legislature discussed adding treadmills as a form of “labour” and discipline to two new prisons being erected in Philadelphia and Pittsburgh.
Post writer Douglas C. Rigg reported on the mental and emotional anguish of prison inmates who had been given life sentences, and the argument for reforming America’s concept of “punishment” in 1957.
In 1957, the Post questioned the legitimacy of practices at Illinois State Penitentiary, where the emphasis was security and confinement of inmates, not reform.
Become a Saturday Evening Post member and enjoy unlimited access. Subscribe now