The Creation of Nancy Drew

It took a tenacious, bold, independent writer to invent the fictional teen sleuth.

Cover for the Nancy Drew novel, The Secret of the Old Clock, by Carolyn Keene

Weekly Newsletter

The best of The Saturday Evening Post in your inbox!

SUPPORT THE POST

Nancy Drew struggled this way and that. She twisted and squirmed. She kicked and clawed. But she was powerless in the grip of the man.

“Little wildcat! You won’t do any more scratching when I get through with you!”

“Let me go!” Nancy cried, struggling harder. The man half-carried, half-dragged her across the room. Opening the closet door, he flung her roughly inside. Nancy heard a key turn in the lock. The sliding of a bolt into place followed.

“Now you can starve for all I care!” the man laughed harshly. Then the steady tramp of his heavy boots across the floor told Nancy Drew that he had left the house.

The Secret of the Old Clock (1930 edition)

As any of the generations of fans of the fictional girl detective Nancy Drew — heroine of hundreds of serial novels published from 1930 to this day — can tell you, Nancy does not stay locked in the closet for long. She tries to pick the lock with a hairpin, then uses a clothing rod to pry off the hinges while giving one of her trademark side lectures — this time, on Archimedes and the wedge.

This teenage detective became the archetype of a kind of tough American woman: smart and fierce in the face of violence, but also well respected by police and her doting father. Fashionable, too. Even though she was just a fictional character, she was inspirational, and none other than Supreme Court Justices Sandra Day O’Connor, Ruth Bader Ginsburg, and Sonia Sotomayor have said she was a huge influence in their lives.

Over the course of more than 600 books, Nancy Drew unearthed lost wills and heirlooms and found missing people. She explored hidden staircases and spooky haunted houses. Tenacious and plucky, Nancy had a boyfriend, the handsome Ned. She always fought to right wrongs, using her smarts to wriggle out of perilous situations. Nancy Drew got kidnapped. She was knocked unconscious. Foes threatened her to stay off cases (or else!).

What she offered American girls was a sense of resourcefulness. She taught us to signal SOS with a tube of lipstick, to break out of a window using spike heels, and to always keep an overnight bag in our car — a girl never knew when she’d encounter a sudden overnight sleuthing adventure. Real-life kidnapping victims have said that Nancy Drew stories inspired them to use their wits to escape; successful women in law enforcement say Nancy Drew led them to their careers.

The real mystery of Nancy Drew is how such a fictional character could inspire real women. Clues can be found in the woman, Mildred ­Augustine Wirt Benson, who fleshed out the young detective’s personality. Many different writers worked on Nancy Drew’s stories, which were always published under the pen name of Carolyn Keene. But the very first books in the series, the ones that established her particular steely bravery, were written by Benson, who was just as tenacious and bold and independent as her heroine. Benson sought adventure and bucked conventions throughout her life. Once, she was even locked in a room.

Mildred Augustine was born in 1905 in Ladora, Iowa, a rural farming community near Iowa City. An avid reader of children’s classics like Louisa May Alcott’s Little Women, children’s magazines, and serial fiction, she preferred the books written for boys over those for girls, she said, because they focused on adventure and action.

The young Benson liked to write. When she was 13, her short story “The Courtesy” appeared in St. Nicholas, a monthly children’s magazine that also published notable authors like Louisa May Alcott, Mark Twain, and F. Scott Fitzgerald. The story won a second-­place silver badge in a monthly contest. “When I grow up, I’m going to be a great writer,” Benson later recalled saying.

[Nancy Drew] was treated as an equal by her father and by many in law enforcement, and she never gave up when the going got hard. Her spirit struck a chord.

In rural Ladora, there were few career opportunities for women outside of domestic pursuits. Most girls planned on raising families and helping run the farms. Benson was a country doctor’s daughter who often rode with her father on patient calls, and that life was never in the cards. Benson’s parents encouraged her to get a college education and pursue adventure and her writing career. She graduated early from high school and enrolled in the University of Iowa, excelling in her classes and as a championship diver. She graduated with a degree in English in 1925, and soon after in 1927, she would become the first student, man or woman, to earn a master’s degree in journalism at Iowa. She traveled to New York, where she began pursuing her long-sought career in writing.

During her first trip to New York, she met a businessman named Edward Stratemeyer whose company, the Stratemeyer Syndicate, hired ghostwriters to write popular books. For a flat fee, these writers produced manuscripts based on outlines provided by the syndicate, signing away their authorship rights. Stratemeyer then attributed the books to pseudonymous authors and farmed them out to publishers. It was a very successful business model that churned out popular series such as The Bobbsey Twins, Ruth Fielding, Tom Swift, and The Hardy Boys, the boys’ detective serial that had started in 1927. “As oil has its Rockefeller, literature has its Stratemeyer,” Fortune magazine wrote of the publishing magnate in 1934.

Stratemeyer didn’t have work for Benson right away, but he soon hired her to work on the Ruth Fielding series, which she had read as a child, and then asked her to help him launch a new series about a teenage girl detective named Nancy Drew. The three-page outline Stratemeyer wrote for the first Nancy Drew book, The Secret of the Old Clock, set a tone for his new protagonist, whom he described as “an up-to-date American girl at her best, bright, clever, resourceful, and full of energy.”

He mailed the document to Benson, who set out to breathe life into the sleuthing heroine, giving her a healthy dose of her own independence, bravery, and feistiness.

Nancy Drew author Carolyn Keene (real name, Mildred Augustine Writ Benson) sits at a desk with a collection of her books.
Dream job: Benson decided to become a great writer when she was only 13. (Courtesy The University of Iowa)

Benson’s original Nancy Drew, depicted in books such as The Hidden Staircase, The Secret at Shadow Ranch, and The Clue in the Crumbling Wall, was a brash and daring sleuth. The 1930s and 1940s, when this first Nancy Drew debuted, were a time when girls who liked to read were ready for something more than the norm — those books Benson described as “namby pamby” girls’ series of the time. Life was hard for kids during the Great Depression and World War II, and parents didn’t sugarcoat the evil in the world. ­Reading about an adventurous girl who faced down the dangers around her provided young readers a safe escape from the troubles of the day, while also offering a nod to difficult times. Benson’s Nancy Drew paved the way for all of the others that followed, though the character was softened in later years.

Nancy Drew was independent and was not tied down by work, domestic pursuits, or a fretting mother (hers had died). She was treated as an equal by her father and by many in law enforcement, and she never gave up when the going got hard. Her spirit struck a chord. Nancy Drew personified “the dream image which exists within most teenagers,” Benson wrote in an autobiographical essay in 1973. This teen of the 1930s remained culturally relevant for more than 80 years, even as young women’s roles changed dramatically. Mothers and grandmothers passed the books down to their daughters. “Women still tell me how they identified with Nancy Drew and that Nancy Drew gave them confidence to be whatever they wanted to be,” she told an interviewer in 1999.

Benson eventually did marry, twice, and had a daughter. But her career always drove her. Between 1926 and 1959, she wrote 135 books, including 23 of the first 30 Nancy Drew books. Benson published some novels under her own name, including her favorite, Penny Parker Mystery Stories, and books in Stratemeyer Syndicate series like The Dana Girls and Honey Bunch.

Benson also worked as a journalist for more than 50 years, mainly in Toledo, Ohio, at The Toledo Times and the Toledo Blade. She worked the courthouse beat, tenaciously shaking out the facts about local crimes and city corruption. Later she wrote features, aviation columns, and a popular column for active seniors.

After all those years of writing series books adventures, Benson embarked on real-life adventures. During the 1960s, she trained to become a pilot and traveled to Central America to view ancient Mayan sites before they were opened to widespread tourism. She traveled alone, braving crocodile-infested rivers and jungles she had to hack through with a machete. She was even once locked inside a room, in Guatemala in the early 1960s, by some locals who thought she knew too much about criminal activity in their town. (In that moment, Benson later said, she ruefully thought, “What would Nancy do?”) Eventually Benson, in true Nancy Drew style, overpowered one of her captors and escaped. Like any good sleuth, she later returned to Guatemala to learn more about what had happened to her.

It would be decades before most Nancy Drew fans learned that Benson was the original Carolyn Keene — the Stratemeyers always kept authors’ identities under wraps, preferring to tell fans that the family wrote all the books. The truth slowly leaked out, starting in the 1970s, thanks to researchers who discovered Benson had been Carolyn Keene. In the early 1990s, Benson donated a series of papers and her Underwood typewriter to the Smithsonian Institution’s National Museum of American History. And in 1993, the University of Iowa held a widely publicized Nancy Drew Conference, after which Benson finally got the public credit and adulation she deserved. She was even named the “Person of the Week” by ABC’s World News Tonight with Peter Jennings.

Benson told Jennings that she’d probably still be writing when the undertaker walked through the door. She was right — she was working in semi-retirement on a column for the Toledo Blade on May 28, 2002, the day she died, at age 96.

This essay is part of What It Means to Be American, a project of the Smithsonian’s National Museum of American History and Arizona State University, produced by Zócalo Public Square.

This article is featured in the March/April 2019 issue of The Saturday Evening Post. Subscribe to the magazine for more art, inspiring stories, fiction, humor, and features from our archives.

 

Become a Saturday Evening Post member and enjoy unlimited access. Subscribe now

Comments

  1. Many thanks to the Stratemeyers! I loved Nancy Drew, Judy Bolton, Honey Bunch, & didn’t, waaay back then , even think of giving credit to the publishers of our favorite reads. We (yep, me, too) love to write, but w/out an encouraging publisher, our shelves would only be filled with our own works.

    This was such an interesting article, heartwarming to readers like me who loved Carolyn Keene works. Thanks!!!

    PS. I’m in my 70s, too.

  2. It was so much fun reading Nancy Drew books with my friends and we often traded books. I would find the books with bluish covers and some with the yellow covers at our local thrift stores. I still have quite a collection and every now and then I love to re-read the stories. Since I was such a shy young girl I always admired how brave Nancy was in so many situations!

  3. I’m 72 now and 3 years ago decided to re-read my favorite books of all times-Nancy Drew. In this second reading at first I hurried through them but have now settled down to just a chapter a day. I have a list to follow but not in order. Tomorrow I’ll start my #38 The Secret of Mirror Lake. 17 more to go. It’s great fun still!

  4. Nancy Drew!!! When much younger, I hardly read anything else but the Nancy Drew books. I don’t actually remember, but I like to think books about Nancy Drew inspired my contribution during a later year to my own sister’s name, which was naturally Nancy! I enjoyed this article very much.

  5. I started reading Nancy Drew right before I entered junior high, probably in the sixth grade. I also read Honey Bunch, the Bobbsey Twins, Trixie Belden, and my personal favorite, Judy Bolton. I read a couple of Hardy Boys, but since I am a girl, didn’t really find them as interesting as the girly ones! I still love mysteries to this day, but also love historicals. I am a steady reader and have also written my own books (unpublished). I do thank “Carolyn Keene” for her inspiration.

  6. I am 63. Although I read my first Nancy Drew books in the mid-60s (the yellow ones) when I was 12 I moved to Florida to stay with my grandparents for the summer. There local library was a small donated room with only donated books. Someone had donated 1920-1940 editions of Nancy Drew in the brown covers. You can tell the older ones because Nancy is described as having “Titian” hair. I have been hooked on mystery books ever since.

  7. So thrilled that author Christy Barritt share this article on fb!!
    I must go back and re-read Nancy Drew!

  8. I loved Nancy Drew stories! Nancy sparked my lifelong love of mystery fiction. Without Nancy, I wouldn’t be a dedicated Sherlockian, traveling to other parts of the country to do presentations about the Holmes and his Victorian world.

  9. My USAF father was stationed at Greenham Common AFB, England (1956 – 1959) when I discovered the Nancy Drew series of books. Forget dolls and other toys because all I ever wanted for Christmas or my birthday was just one more Nancy Drew mystery, please.

  10. I enjoyed Nancy Drew books when I was quite young — can’t remember how old. My aunt brought my first
    one and got me hooked.

    I’m 75 now and to this day I still read – almost constantly- and mostly mysteries. Love trying to figure out
    “who done it”.

    Thanks for writing this article about Nancy Drew’s originator, which was great. Wonder if anyone ever finished her last book she was writing when she died.

  11. I discovered Nancy Drew when I was 10 years old. I was in the hospital for a month with ruptured appendix and the nurses brought me Nancy Drew books. I read one a day and to this day I love mystery books. I am now 86.

  12. I read all of the Nancy Drew books beginning when I was eight years old and kept the books until after I was married and had a family. Every Saturday my dad would take me to the book store and buy me a book. I read them over and over. The books were a great influence on my philosophy and attitude throughout my life. I am now 82 years old and still fondly remember my enjoyment of Nancy Drew.

  13. I am 83 and started reading books as soon as I learned to read. I started with The Bobbsey Twins and Honey Bunch, then graduated to dear Nancy Drew. All I ever wanted for my birthday or Christmas was a book. I also read Cherry Ames, Student Nurse, and Vicky Barr, stewardess. I think I remember those names correctly. There was another series of books about a little girl named Maida who was very rich. Does anyone remember that series?

    I loved the article about Benson. She was a woman to emulate.

  14. I am 76 yrs old and Nancy Drew was my constant reading when I was young. She was my mentor
    I had a collection of books and passed them on to my cousin who is now in her late 50s

  15. Thank you for the Nancy Drew article. I am 72 years old and was also greatly influenced by the books.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *