How to Get Major Life Decisions Right

Dr. Jim Taylor walks you through six facets to consider when you are faced with a major decision.

Feet in front of two arrows

Weekly Newsletter

The best of The Saturday Evening Post in your inbox!


I recently had dinner with a former client I had worked with about 15 years ago. Cassie (not her real name) was in her teens then. She is now a grown woman with a great career and about to be married. She asked for my guidance to help her make a major career decision involving two options.

She can stay at her current job which requires 60-80 hours a week, is very stressful, and prevents her from having any balance in her life. At the same time, it is pays well and could lead to a more desired position in the future.

Or she can take a position with smaller company that would demand less time, have less stress, but also pays less and might limit one particularly desirable future career opportunity.

Cassie asked for my thoughts on how to make the best decision possible. Her predicament resonated with me because it is one that I have faced often in my own life and that I regularly counsel clients on in my professional life.

The crux of this major life decision is one simple question: “How do I make the right decision that will have such a huge impact on my life when it isn’t at all clear what the best decision is?” Here’s what I told Cassie.

There are no crystal balls in life, so no way to know what lies in the future. Attempting to predict the future is a largely frustrating and futile endeavor. You can only make the best decision you can based on the available information, some contemplation of the career and life you want to lead, and your present feelings. Also, recognize that this isn’t your final decision on your career and life; you will have many “forks in the road” ahead of you and few are irreversible (except parenthood!). That should help put the decision in perspective and reduce its feeling of enormity.

There are several facets of this decision that you can consider (with some relevant tangents thrown in as well).

First, what is the objective reality of the two options you face, meaning how will the two paths impact you? A big part of this involves giving a lot of thought to what you want. In Cassie’s case, how will the decision influence her identified career dream goal? Can she live comfortably with less money that will come if she changes jobs? Will the new job really mean fewer hours and less stress? How will either path impact her upcoming marriage, having a family, being a mother, and her overall quality of life? What are the implications of this decision on her future financial goals?

Second, don’t base decisions on something that may or may not happen in the future. I asked Cassie to consider if she really needed her current job to get that dream job that she coveted. Things may change in the future such that she may no longer want that “ideal” job (dreams have a way of changing over time). There no way to know what unexpected and wonderful things may happen. Plus, serendipity has an amazing way of changing our lives.

A third facet of decision-making involves a deep exploration of your values, priorities, and the lifestyle you want to lead. What do you value most in your life? What aspects of your life do you want as your priorities? What kind of life do you want to lead in the short term and in the future, say, in 10+ years? What do you want your life to be filled with (e.g., marriage, children, travel, health and exercise, culture)? I have found that people don’t have this discussion nearly enough or soon enough and they end up just following the path of least resistance and what everyone else is doing.

A fourth consideration is to recognize that time is your most precious resource. Why? Because it is nonrenewable. It’s has always been a priority of mine over money. Don’t get me wrong, I like money because there are some experiences and things that I want to have that cost money (e.g., travel, good education for my children, bikes, skis). Here’s a great question to ask: At the end of your life, how do you wish you had lived your life and spent your time? Will you regret working so much despite the financial reward, or will you look back with satisfaction knowing that you lived your life the way you deliberately chose to?

A fifth facet is entirely nonrational and hard to wrap your arms around. I’m referring to your intuition, your gut — whatever you want to call it. When you think about the two different paths, how do they feel? Which one brings you a sense of calm and comfort and which one brings you angst and discomfort? In looking back at the many forks in the road I have taken, I have found that my gut feeling was usually right. Making a decision in this intuitive way is truly a leap of faith because there is no objective data on which to base your decision. The challenge for you is that it requires a great deal of trust in that nonrational part of you.

That brings me to a very important sixth facet; namely, your happiness. As I have progressed through my life, I have found that happiness should be central to all of our life’s decisions. Yes, success and financial rewards can bring you satisfaction (and it does pay the bills), but only happiness can bring you real meaning, fulfillment, and joy. True happiness comes from living a life filled with your passions, finding love, living a value-driven life, and your life not being about you. So, what makes you happy and unhappy? If your current situation is that bad, run away from it as fast as you can (life is too short).

Finally, if it’s any consolation as you wrestle with major life decisions, there are no bad decisions here. The reality is that, whatever you decide, you will be just fine because you’re a competent and good person who will make the best of whichever path you choose. But, if you asked me what I would do in your situation, I would lean toward what your gut is saying and what will make you happiest now. Your future will, I believe, take care of itself quite nicely.

Featured image: Shutterstock

Become a Saturday Evening Post member and enjoy unlimited access. Subscribe now


Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *