Classic Covers: Halloween

Jack-o'-lanterns, masks, and merriment—in the early 1900s, the ghoulish holiday wasn't so different than it is today.

Teddy the Pumpkin by J.C. Leyendecker

Weekly Newsletter

The best of The Saturday Evening Post in your inbox!


Jack-o’-lanterns, masks, and merriment—in the early 1900s, the ghoulish holiday wasn’t so different than it is today.

Teddy the Pumpkin

Teddy the Pumpkin by J.C. Leyendecker From October 26, 1912

Teddy the Pumpkin
J.C. Leyendecker
October 26, 1912


Theodore Roosevelt was the U.S. president from 1901-1909. Yet in 1912, when this J.C. Leyendecker cover (left) appeared, Roosevelt was still a force of nature. That same year, he had a falling out with former good friend and then-President William Howard Taft and decided to challenge him in the upcoming election. The Republican bigwigs favored Taft though people like this youngster said “Bully!” for Roosevelt.

Halloween, 1904

Halloween, 1904 by Anne Estelle Rice From October 29, 1904

Halloween, 1904
Anne Estelle Rice
October 29, 1904


In the 1930s, Anne Estelle Rice (1877-1959) left illustration and began a career designing operatic sets and costumes in London. But her passion for theater was showcased in her illustrations, such as the 1904 cover (left). Rice often drew figures in theatrical costumes and settings. This cover is one of three she did for the Post; the contour lines and simple details shown in the uncomplicated silhouette are definitive of her style.

Woman in Masquerade Costume

Woman in Masquerade Costume by Allan Gilbert From October 12, 1907

Woman in Masquerade Costume
C. Allan Gilbert
October 12, 1907


An invalid as a child, Charles Allan Gilbert (1873-1929) drew pictures to entertain himself. He officially took up the study of art at age 16, and at 21 he studied for a year at the Académie Julian in Paris, where greats such as J.C. Leyendecker were trained.

Gilbert chose beautiful, buxom women as subjects, much like his contemporaries: Charles Dana Gibson and Howard Chandler Christy. Besides four covers for the Post, Gilbert illustrated books, posters, and calendars, but his work is often overlooked for the one image he is best remembered for: The intriguing 1892 double image called All is Vanity.

Looking for Future Husband

Country Gentleman, Looking for Future Husband by F. Lowenheim From October 28, 1922

Looking for Future Husband
F. Lowenheim
October 28, 1922
Country Gentleman


German-born Frederick Lowenheim (1870–1929) was a storybook illustrator in the early 1900s. Like his book illustrations, Lowenheim’s 15 covers for Country Gentleman were often scenes depicting children in amusing situations, such as the Halloween prank on the October 28, 1922, cover (left).

A poem from an early 1900s postcard explains the girl’s horrified expression: “On Hallowe’en look in the glass, Your future husband’s face will pass.”

Halloween Fiddler

Country Gentleman Halloween Fiddler by Norman Rockwell From October 22, 1921

Halloween Fiddler
Norman Rockwell
Country Gentleman, October 22, 1921


Norman Rockwell painted 35 covers for Country Gentleman, which like The Saturday Evening Post, was published by Curtis Publishing Company. Known as “a journal for the farm, the garden, and the fireside,” Country Gentleman‘s content included farm news, gardening and canning advice, and fiction.

Most of Rockwell’s covers for the farm centric magazine centered around a character he created: city-slicker Reginald, who visits his country cousins frequently, only to be made the butt of their jokes.

In the 1921 Halloween cover (left), however, Rockwell shows us a more peaceable side to country living.

Become a Saturday Evening Post member and enjoy unlimited access. Subscribe now


  1. Continued.(I clicked send by mistake too soon!) ‘Future Husband’ is great too. Poor girl, especially if she believed the poem, which it appears she does, unfortunately–at least for the present.

    ‘Halloween Fiddle’ Great C.G. cover. It doesn’t “look” like a Rockwell as such, but not like it couldn’t be either. It’s fascinating–and that includes the pumpkin; great carving!

  2. ‘Teddy the Pumpkin’ That is one heck of a in incerdible pumpkin carving and really does look like Roosevelt. It’s almost as big as this boy AND it’s 100 years ago this week.

    ‘Halloween 1904’ What an interesting artist this woman was. I’d like to further into her work!

    ‘Masquerade’ Another artist I really like and not previously familiar with. He’s wonderful and his work does seem to have a Gibson/Christy influence to it. I don’t mind a bit.

  3. I love seeing the old “Post” and “Country Gentleman” covers by the different illustrators.

  4. What a delightful way to spend an afternoon waiting for the storm, thinking about and seeing cartoons and covers from The Saturday Evening Post!


Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *